Strategy & Consultancy

Is 'The Best Person for the Job' Just a Myth? Let's Talk About What 'Merit' Really Means

"May the best person win." This age-old adage seems fair and straightforward, but is it really? We often believe that in our workplaces, the most qualified individual gets the job or the promotion. However, beneath this seemingly clear surface lies a complex reality of biases and preconceptions that we might not be aware of. Let's unravel the intricacies behind what we often take for granted in our quest for meritocracy.

Blog foto 10

The Unseen Bias

It's easy to assume that our professional decisions are always rational and fair. However, research suggests otherwise. In settings where meritocracy is the declared norm, people's judgments can be skewed by unconscious biases. Ironically, in our efforts to be fair and objective, we might unknowingly favor certain groups over others, even when qualifications are identical. This bias isn't always intentional or overt; it often operates subtly, influencing decisions without our conscious awareness.

Consider the case of Hajar and Walter, both finalists for a senior manager position at a renowned tech company. They have similar qualifications and experiences. Yet, the hiring committee, while believing they are making a purely merit-based decision, leans towards Walter. Without realizing, their decision is influenced by the stereotype that men are more suited for leadership roles in tech. Hajar, despite her equal merits, faces an invisible barrier.

The role of subconscious perceptions

These biases stem from our subconscious perceptions of what makes someone 'qualified' or 'capable.' Cultural stereotypes, like in Hajar and Walter’s case, can play a significant role in these perceptions. The belief that one demographic is inherently more competent than another can lead to unequal evaluation of equally qualified candidates.

Challenging the status quo

Recognizing these hidden biases is the first step in challenging them. It's not enough to proclaim fairness; we must actively seek it out in our actions and decisions. This means questioning our assumptions about merit and qualifications and being open to the idea that our understanding of these concepts might be flawed.

Creating truly fair workplaces

The journey towards genuinely fair workplaces involves more than just acknowledging these biases. It requires a commitment to continuous learning and improvement, to ensure that opportunities are truly based on merit. This might involve rethinking how we assess qualifications and potential, and being more critical of our decision-making processes.

The myth of meritocracy isn't just a theoretical issue; it has real implications for how we run our organizations and how individuals experience their professional lives. By confronting and understanding the biases that cloud our judgment, we can move closer to creating workplaces where 'the best person for the job' is not just a hopeful ideal, but a reality grounded in fairness and equality.

Written bySana Sellami

minute read

Share this post

Related articles

In the wake of March, a month marked by pivotal moments such as International Women's Day and the International Day Against Racism and Discrimination,…
Read more
You've taken the first step: drafting a strategic plan for diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). That's a milestone you should be proud of! But what happens…
Read more
Employee Resource Groups (ERGs) have transcended their original purpose as safe havens for underrepresented employees to voice their concerns. Today, they…
Read more

Follow me!